Is it OK to Laugh About it?

Holocaust Humour, Satire and Parody in Israeli Culture

Vallentine Mitchell 2017

For many years, Israeli culture recoiled from dealing with the Holocaust from a humorous or satirical perspective. The perception was that a humorous approach might threaten the sanctity of its memory, or evoke feelings of disrespect towards the subject and hurt Holocaust survivors' feelings. But, from the 1990s, a new unofficial path of commemoration has been taking shape. Texts that combine the Holocaust with humour, satire, and parody are a major aspect of it, but this remains controversial. Often, Holocaust humour is perceived as part of a dangerous process that normalizes Nazism and Hitler. In opposition to these ideas, author Steir-Livny claims that in Israel, a unique post-traumatic society where the trauma lives as an integral part of the present, Holocaust humour in Hebrew functions as an important defence mechanism. The book argues that Holocaust humour, satire, and parody rebel against the way this trauma affects Israeli society in the present by challenging and deconstructing the fear. Is It Ok to Laugh About It? shows that paradoxically, Holocaust humour also strengthens the dominance of the trauma in the present by inserting it even more into everyday life and popular culture. Thus, Holocaust humour, satire, and parody in Israel are a double-edged sword: on the one hand, they function as an attempt to fight the acting out of the trauma in Israeli society but, on the other, they strengthen certain elements of it. There is a contradictory process of dissociation and assimilation occurring at the same time, which attests to the dominance of the trauma in the Jewish-Israelis' identity. This innovative and intriguing analysis will challenge the borders of Holocaust research and commemoration.

Review: Ivanova Alyona, “Book Review:  Is It OK to Laugh about It?”, European Journal of Humour Research 6 (4), 2018, pp. 145–150

Is it OK to Laugh About it?

Holocaust Humour, Satire and Parody in Israeli Culture

Vallentine Mitchell 2017

For many years, Israeli culture recoiled from dealing with the Holocaust  from a humorous or satirical perspective. The perception was that a  humorous approach might threaten the sanctity of its memory, or evoke  feelings of disrespect towards the subject and hurt Holocaust survivors'  feelings. But, from the 1990s, a new unofficial path of commemoration  has been taking shape. Texts that combine the Holocaust with humour,  satire, and parody are a major aspect of it, but this remains  controversial. Often, Holocaust humour is perceived as part of a  dangerous process that normalizes Nazism and Hitler. In opposition to  these ideas, author Steir-Livny claims that in Israel, a unique  post-traumatic society where the trauma lives as an integral part of the  present, Holocaust humour in Hebrew functions as an important defence  mechanism. The book argues that Holocaust humour, satire, and parody  rebel against the way this trauma affects Israeli society in the present  by challenging and deconstructing the fear. Is It Ok to Laugh About It?  shows that paradoxically, Holocaust humour also strengthens the  dominance of the trauma in the present by inserting it even more into  everyday life and popular culture. Thus, Holocaust humour, satire, and  parody in Israel are a double-edged sword: on the one hand, they  function as an attempt to fight the acting out of the trauma in Israeli  society but, on the other, they strengthen certain elements of it. There  is a contradictory process of dissociation and assimilation occurring  at the same time, which attests to the dominance of the trauma in the  Jewish-Israelis' identity. This innovative and intriguing analysis will  challenge the borders of Holocaust research and commemoration.